Wednesday, January 22, 2025

Damdar Mukhyamantri : Redefining Governance with Liquor Ban

 Dr. Deepak Rai, Bhopal
Dr. Deepak Rai Author


In a state that thrives on traditions, spirituality, and vibrant cultures, the idea of banning liquor seems both ambitious and audacious. Madhya Pradesh's Chief Minister, Dr. Mohan Yadav, recently made headlines with his bold proclamation: “Liquor ban will be implemented at many places in Madhya Pradesh.” Coming at a time when the state's Excise Department has projected a staggering revenue target of ₹16,000 crore from liquor sales for the fiscal year 2025–26, this statement is nothing short of revolutionary.


The move signifies a dramatic shift in governance philosophy, one that prioritizes societal and spiritual well-being over fiscal dependencies. The policy, although not entirely novel, evokes a sense of déjà vu. Former Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan once ventured into moral prohibitions—banning public drinking and closing liquor vends near schools and temples. But where Chouhan stopped short of full prohibition, Dr. Yadav is charting a far more radical path.


Dr. Mohan Yadav’s stance isn’t impulsive but appears to be a culmination of a meticulously planned strategy. The seeds of this movement were sown as early as February 2024, merely two months after Yadav assumed office. Under his direction, a crackdown on illegal liquor trade swept across the state. Illegal shops were shuttered, illicit distilleries dismantled, and violators prosecuted under stringent sections of the Indian Penal Code, including Section 272 (adulteration of food or drink intended for sale). This initial wave of action not only showcased the administration's resolve but also laid the groundwork for a broader societal shift.


The CM’s choice to start this ambitious plan from Ujjain—the city synonymous with religion, spirituality, and historical significance—is emblematic. As the epicenter of the Mahakal Corridor and a city that thrives on tourism and pilgrimage, Ujjain’s symbolic value cannot be overstated. Critics who once mocked Yadav for Ujjain’s high liquor revenues—up by nearly 20% in 2024—now find themselves silenced.


It’s not just rhetoric. The new excise policy being crafted for 2025–26 is likely to include provisions to close liquor shops in key religious hubs like Ujjain, Amarkantak, and Omkareshwar. This move resonates with Gandhiji’s vision, who once said, “Alcohol makes a man forget himself. It is a disease, not a necessity.” The Chief Minister appears to embody this principle, recognizing that good governance goes beyond financial gains.


Historically, excise revenues have been a financial cornerstone for many states. Madhya Pradesh, for instance, earned ₹13,914 crore from liquor sales in 2024, a 12.63% increase from the previous year. Such figures are compelling, often dissuading governments from pursuing prohibition. After all, this revenue funds critical infrastructure, healthcare, and education projects. However, Dr. Yadav’s conviction stems from a deeper understanding of societal cost versus financial gain. The social fabric of Madhya Pradesh, home to revered spiritual traditions, cannot be compromised for economic expediency.


Opposition parties, unsurprisingly, have seized the opportunity to question the practicality of prohibition. Detractors argue that banning liquor will drive its trade underground, leading to a surge in bootlegging and spurious alcohol—an issue that has plagued dry states like Gujarat and Bihar. But Dr. Yadav’s administration appears prepared to counter these challenges. By strengthening law enforcement and community awareness campaigns, the government aims to minimize the loopholes that illicit traders exploit.


One cannot ignore the cultural and moral dimensions of this initiative. Prohibition, if executed effectively, can lead to profound societal transformation. Alcohol abuse is often linked to domestic violence, road accidents, and deteriorating public health. A report from the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) highlights that nearly 30% of violent crimes in India are committed under the influence of alcohol. In this context, prohibition is not just a policy but a step toward reclaiming the sanctity of family and society.


Dr. Yadav’s bold move has rekindled memories of earlier attempts at liquor bans in India. Bihar’s Chief Minister Nitish Kumar implemented a similar prohibition in 2016, which reportedly led to a significant drop in crime rates but also invited criticism for its enforcement challenges. Madhya Pradesh now stands at a similar crossroads, and the lessons from other states will undoubtedly inform its strategy.


However, the success of prohibition hinges on more than just political will. Public support is crucial. Madhya Pradesh’s diverse demographic—ranging from tribal communities to urban elites—presents a unique challenge. Awareness campaigns must address the root causes of alcohol dependence while offering viable alternatives for recreational and social activities. Rehabilitation centers, skill development programs, and counseling services must complement the prohibition policy.


It is also essential to consider the economic ripple effects of this decision. The closure of liquor shops will impact thousands employed in the sector, from shop workers to supply chain professionals. For this, the government must devise a robust transition plan. Perhaps incentives for industries like tourism, handicrafts, and agriculture can fill the economic void. As Mahatma Gandhi once said, “The best way to find yourself is to lose yourself in the service of others.” Dr. Yadav’s government must channel resources into uplifting those affected by the ban, ensuring that prohibition becomes an instrument of empowerment rather than deprivation.


While cynics might dismiss this move as political posturing, there is no denying its transformative potential. If successful, Madhya Pradesh could become a model for other states grappling with similar dilemmas. Imagine a state where religious sanctity coexists with progressive governance, where the health and happiness of citizens are prioritized over excise profits.


Dr. Mohan Yadav’s vision for Madhya Pradesh aligns with the words of Swami Vivekananda: “Arise, awake, and stop not till the goal is reached.” This is a clarion call not just for governance but for societal introspection. The journey toward prohibition will be fraught with challenges, but as history has shown, great leaders are defined by their ability to navigate uncharted waters.


If Madhya Pradesh implements a complete liquor ban, starting with its religious cities, it will mark a historic milestone. Dr. Mohan Yadav’s name may indeed be etched in golden letters, not just in state history but in the annals of Indian governance.


For now, the CM stands as a beacon of hope, reminding us that courage and conviction can pave the way for a better tomorrow. As the policy unfolds, the entire nation watches with bated breath. Will Madhya Pradesh set the stage for a social renaissance? Only time will tell.



No comments: